Foreword
In the rapidly evolving world of projection technology, projectors have transitioned from being purely office tools to becoming favored devices for individual users. The competition over light sources has always been fierce. LED projectors offer longevity, low heat generation, and high reliability, while traditional bulbs provide brightness and a great viewing experience. Laser projectors, although costly, promise durability and superior brightness. However, the trajectory of projection technology truly depends on user perception, technological maturity, and cost reductions. Today, I’m excited to discuss two of the most prominent light sources in modern projectors: LEDs and lasers. I’ve also got my hands on models featuring these light sources for a comparative experience.
Difference Between LED and Laser
LED light sources are known for their long lifespan, low heat production, high reliability, and eco-friendly attributes, which have contributed to their rise in popularity. Despite these benefits, certain limitations like narrower color gamuts and lower brightness have prompted many to shift their focus toward laser light sources, which boast wider color gamuts and higher brightness levels.
In terms of color gamut, standard white LEDs fall short of the standard range, while color LEDs only marginally exceed it. Laser light sources, however, far surpass the standard color gamut.
When it comes to brightness, 1000 lumens marks a significant milestone for LED projectors. Currently, only a few models on the market have achieved this threshold. Traditional bulb projectors struggle to meet this benchmark, whereas laser projectors easily bridge this gap. They not only address issues like bulb lifespan and high power consumption but also deliver substantial brightness improvements. This might explain why lasers are increasingly viewed as the future of projection technology.
Of course, the downside of lasers remains their relatively high cost. Nevertheless, as technology advances, laser projectors will likely become more affordable and accessible, potentially sparking a revolution in the projector or even television industries.
Parameters
To give a simple comparison, we’ll look at Cool Music’s S3 and Light Peak’s A1. Cool Music positioned the S3 as one of its standout releases last year. It aims to deliver household-projector lumens at a consumer-friendly price. Light Peak’s A1, meanwhile, seems reasonably priced within the laser projector segment. Both models offer 700 ANSI and 1000 ANSI lumens respectively (note: Cool LeTV’s S3 standard edition also hovers around 700 ANSI). Their resolutions are identical, with the primary distinction being their respective light sources—LED versus laser.
Design
From a design perspective, the two projectors differ significantly. Cool Music’s S3 has a square shape, while Light Peak’s A1 is rectangular. Additionally, A1’s metallic build feels more premium compared to the resin material used in S3. In terms of ergonomics, A1 outshines S3.
Installation-wise, Cool Music’s S3 features a standard threaded hole, allowing easy mounting options like ceiling lifts, wall mounts, and tripods. Unfortunately, Light Peak’s A1 lacks this feature, which is somewhat disappointing.
As for connectivity, Cool Music’s S3 offers more ports, including two USBs, two HDMI inputs, Ethernet support, and compatibility with AV and DTMB. Light Peak’s A1, however, boasts a USB 3.0 port for faster data transfer. Ultimately, the choice depends on your specific needs.
Projection Ratio
We’re not comparing aesthetics here but rather focusing on the projection effect. Let’s start with the throw ratio (projector distance to screen width). Short-throw projectors are trending for home use since they allow larger images in fixed spaces. Placing both projectors in the same position, we projected onto a screen. As shown below, the red-framed image represents Light Peak A1’s projection, while the outer layer is Cool Music S3’s. In the same position, S3’s screen is approximately 1.6 times larger than A1’s.
For a clearer comparison, observe the side-by-side images below. The top is Cool Music S3’s projection, and the bottom is Light Peak A1’s. These were taken at 5:00 PM with lights on. Both perform well in ambient lighting conditions.
Brightness and Color
Adjusting the distance between the two projectors, we projected them to the same screen size. As shown below, S3’s brightness is still higher due to its 1000 ANSI lumens compared to A1’s 700 ANSI. However, it’s worth noting that the official claim of "twice the brightness of non-laser projectors" can be misleading. Beyond brightness, there’s a noticeable gap in color reproduction between LED and laser projectors. In our comparison between Cool Music S3 and Light Peak A1, A1’s color reproduction is superior.
Focus Quality
Text performance is another area where Cool Music’s S3 shows some flaws. As shown below, S3 exhibits a noticeable virtual focus issue in the upper-left corner. Meanwhile, Light Peak’s A1 performs better, with all four corners of its projection screen sharp and clear.
Conclusion
After using both projectors, each has its pros and cons. Cool Music’s S3 shines in brightness, while Light Peak’s A1 excels in color reproduction and avoiding virtual focus issues. Both generate considerable heat during use, but A1’s quieter operation contrasts with S3’s louder fan noise. Regarding light sources, lasers seem to be the future of projection technology, with greater potential for development. As technology progresses, laser projectors will likely become more affordable and widely accepted by consumers.
Smart TV/Box Information
For more information on smart TVs and boxes, check out Sofa Butler (http://www.sofabutler.cn), a leading Chinese platform for TV box and smart TV content. It provides updates, discussions, reviews, and resources related to smart TVs, TV boxes, and associated software.
0.5mm Board To Board Connectors
ShenZhen Antenk Electronics Co,Ltd , https://www.antenk.com